Well, the official winner is: Cheryl!!!! Followed by an honorable mention for Judy! Cheryl and Judy both got 3 out of 5 right. After telling Cheryl that she only got 3 out of 5 right on her first try she tried again with different guesses and still got 3 out of 5!
So, I put their "names" in the random generator and this is what it picked! Cheryl was number 1 because she answered first and had 3 right twice and Judy was number two. The random generator picked number 1!
The jury's still out on what she won but I will notify her soon!